The burger was good, but not great. With all the toppings and ketchup I could barely taste the cheese. It was very juicy, cooked the way I asked, and a good size. Fries needed more salt and I wish they'd come with the burger. But a good burger overall!

Three napkin burger. Very juicy. Bun did not hold up well

I do not understand the legendary status of this Burger. I hold this to be an excellent diner burger, but nothing more. The patty is thick and well formed and the beef is tasty (though under salted), and the totality of it is very very pleasant, but in no way transcendent. The value is appalling - for a dollar and a half more I could have a Luger Burger, and not including fries (that are mediocre to begin with) is unimpressive. The ambiance is negligible. Toppings are standard. Perhaps the upper east side venue has more to offer, but we'll never know since it's forever banned from the club.

Not worth the hype.

I think I'd like my fries with my burger, on the plate. The burger itself was good but nothing to write home about. Decent but I could've made it at home.

This is the burger that if you say "hey, let's get a burger", you'd go, and do that, be satisfied and move on. I truly enjoyed it, but as a burger seeker, would put it at the top. The fries were good, the Bloody Mary was a good classic.

Andrew's purple pants and the rest of the excellent company was my favorite part. I'm sad I didn't get a Bloody Mary which was deemed by many to be great. The burger was certainly yummy but average/overrated. Messy, didn't hold together well. I give it a 'meh'. Didn't like the fry chips, though this didn't stop me from eating them.

$12.50 for a cheeseburger with no sides. It was a well cooked, decently seasoned and sized diner-style burger not worthy of any great praise or critique. Another $6 for fries that should've come as an included side.

Andrew, surprisingly, was the first to arrive and made a reservation that wasn't turned down. Amazing. 3.6/10!

Good taste, right temp, cheese melted well but overall not that quinressential "burger" taste you long for when eating a burger. But pretty good.