Papa Ousley's

209 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016

Follow our Adventures!

Overall Rating: 7.98

Taste:

8.26/10

Texture:

8.06/10

Toppings:

6.76/10

Sides:

6.02/10

Value:

8.9/10

Ambiance:

9.76/10

Harmoniousness:

8.12/10

User ratings

Ig "The Mexican beef" M.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

8.4 / 10

Thank you Chip you look really good behind the grill

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

5/10

Value:

9/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Lisa "P.E.T.A (People. Eat. Tasty. Animals) " L.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

8.4 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Andrew "The Moo Pie Pirate" O.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

7.2 / 10

I wanted more goddamn zest chip. But a tasty burg nonetheless

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

6/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

6/10

Greg "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" T.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

5.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

5/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

2/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

5/10

Alissa "LadyPonch" P.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

6.8 / 10

I like Chip's beard.

Rating Details

Taste:

6/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

5/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Dan "The Manwich" M.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

8.6 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

7/10

Value:

8/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Sam "The Meat Hammer" H.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

8.4 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Whitley "Beef. It's What's For Dinner." E.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

Burgers are better in the rain

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Kelly "McWELLdonough" M.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Fay "The Swanson" L.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

6.4 / 10

That boy will fry...

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

5/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

1/10

Brigitte "Virginia Ham" S.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

8.4 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

5/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Hayden "Do Have A Cow, Man" M.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

9.2 / 10

Effortlessly distilled perfection.

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Jason "Wood eye! Wood eye!" W.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

7.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

2/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Laura "Short Rib" G.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

5.6 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

6/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

1/10

Value:

9/10

Harmoniousness:

5/10

Chip "The Back Yard King" W.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

5.2 / 10

I feel the full taste of the burger didn't shine through due to an understuffing of the cheesy middle. Fault can only go to the chef. But the patties molded together nicely to create a wonderful blend along with the beautiful night sky and Empire State Building.

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

1/10

Value:

1/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Lana "Between Two Buns" L.

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger

Rating

7.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

5/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Andrew "The Moo Pie Pirate" O.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

9.4 / 10

I'm totally biased.

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Lisa "P.E.T.A (People. Eat. Tasty. Animals) " L.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

7.4 / 10

Only A little biased

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

1/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

9/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Greg "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" T.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

8.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Ig "The Mexican beef" M.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

7.0 / 10

Great job, but you had tons of help from your mom. Mama's girl!!!!

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

6/10

Value:

8/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Dan "The Manwich" M.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Alissa "LadyPonch" P.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

9.6 / 10

God bless Fay!

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Sam "The Meat Hammer" H.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

9.2 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Whitley "Beef. It's What's For Dinner." E.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

girlpower

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Kelly "McWELLdonough" M.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Brigitte "Virginia Ham" S.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

9.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Hayden "Do Have A Cow, Man" M.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

9.2 / 10

Delightfully original

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Laura "Short Rib" G.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

8.2 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Jason "Wood eye! Wood eye!" W.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

8.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Chip "The Back Yard King" W.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

7.6 / 10

The toppings were so delicious it almost over shadowed the wonderful seasonings in the meat. But with superb grilling and the lighting quick assembly this burger was the one I came back to for seconds. It did help that there were many of them.

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

1/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Lana "Between Two Buns" L.

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger

Rating

9.2 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Greg "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" T.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

8.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Andrew "The Moo Pie Pirate" O.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

9.4 / 10

This is gods work. Well done sir. The complexity was majestic and the creative topping work and hidden cheesy surprise made me quiver with delight.

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Ig "The Mexican beef" M.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

5.4 / 10

I like your tattoos

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

1/10

Value:

6/10

Harmoniousness:

6/10

Dan "The Manwich" M.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

7.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Alissa "LadyPonch" P.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

7.4 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

6/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Sam "The Meat Hammer" H.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

7.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

4/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Whitley "Beef. It's What's For Dinner." E.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

IF I wasn't related to a competitor this would be my number 1!!!!!

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Doug "Vegan1" O.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

7.2 / 10

Too much talk from Andrew. Rating 🌂🌂

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

5/10

Value:

8/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Kelly "McWELLdonough" M.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

8.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

9/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Kelly "McWELLdonough" M.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

8.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

9/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Fay "The Swanson" L.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

4.4 / 10

Needs more salt, alcohol and excersize

Rating Details

Taste:

1/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

5/10

Value:

1/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Brigitte "Virginia Ham" S.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

8.2 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

1/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Laura "Short Rib" G.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

7.6 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

1/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Doug "Vegan1" O.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

8.0 / 10

Too much talk from Andrew. Rating 🌂🌂

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

6/10

Value:

9/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Doug "Vegan1" O.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

5.2 / 10

Too much talk from Andrew. Rating 🌂🌂

Rating Details

Taste:

2/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

1/10

Value:

7/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Jason "Wood eye! Wood eye!" W.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

6.6 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

2/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Chip "The Back Yard King" W.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

7.6 / 10

The grilled onion topping melded perfectly along with a subtle hint of jalapeño and Colby jack that oozed from the meat. The perfectly molded patty was an especially amazing sight.

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

1/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Lisa "P.E.T.A (People. Eat. Tasty. Animals) " L.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

7.8 / 10

This slider needed something, my least favorite out of the three

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

6/10

Lana "Between Two Buns" L.

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger

Rating

8.4 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Burgers

Chip's "Golden Nugget" Burger
7.8/10

Fay's "Halala Back" Burger
8.7/10

Hayden's "Jucy-Lucia" Burger
7.6/10