Papa Ousley's 2016

209 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016

Follow our Adventures!

Overall Rating: 0.0

Taste:

8.64/10

Texture:

8.47/10

Toppings:

8.5/10

Sides:

9.09/10

Value:

9.51/10

Ambiance:

9.9/10

Harmoniousness:

8.6/10

User ratings

Alissa "LadyPonch" P.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.4 / 10

I believe in burgers again. Great flavors. I want to marry this burger.

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Philippe "Taste Bud" T.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.0 / 10

I was happy about this burger. Thanks guys! Thanks to everyone out here who had this great party together with me all the time for life!

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

5/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Samuel "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" L.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.4 / 10

Wonderful flavor! Borscht in a burger!

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Karina "Beef Stroganoff" D.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Loïc "Bocuse Cheap " D.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Zaida "Beefy Dishy" D.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.8 / 10

Delicicious. But a little too hot for My taste

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Pamela "Ground Beef Grail-Seeker" C.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.6 / 10

Fabulous. (Imagine that in cyrillic)

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Doug "Vegan1" O.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

7.4 / 10

The spices reminded me of Andrew's sharp wit.

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

5/10

Harmoniousness:

5/10

Greg "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" T.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.4 / 10

Wow - the fresh dill! Some amazing ingredients in here. I can't say I have had a burger like this, in a good way. Side note: Andrew's hair has been on point for about 30 minutes but I don't see it lasting.

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Andrew "The Moo Pie Pirate" O.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.6 / 10

This was a bold and powerful first entry. Impressive in its inventiveness and the range of explosive flavors that powered into my mouth. Chasing it with a shot of beer vodka only amped up the glory. The only avenue of improvement would be lessening the heat of the horseradish, as it had a tendency to impose itself unnecessarily. Fantastic work.

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Will "Squilly" S.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

8.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Ally "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" G.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

Horseradish leaves a nice after taste. Delish

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Chris "Scientaste" W.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

9.2 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Noely "Burgerlicious" Q.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

7.6 / 10

Awesome combination of slider and voka shot

Rating Details

Taste:

5/10

Texture:

5/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Lisa "P.E.T.A (People. Eat. Tasty. Animals) " L.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

This was the best loved the taste toppings and flavor combinations being a beet lover and I like the after burn of the horseradish

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Fay "The Swanson" L.

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger

Rating

8.2 / 10

Very inventive and super tasty! I loved the texture of the hot beats in the meat. The first batch was over cooked but the second was baller.

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Chris "Scientaste" W.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

8.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Karina "Beef Stroganoff" D.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

8.6 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

7/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Philippe "Taste Bud" T.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

8.4 / 10

I loved this burger and this experience very single time!!!

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

6/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Samuel "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" L.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

7.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

7/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

5/10

Will "Squilly" S.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

8.6 / 10

Toppings beautifully complementary. Patty well executed. Juicy.

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Doug "Vegan1" O.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

7.4 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

5/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Pamela "Ground Beef Grail-Seeker" C.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

7.6 / 10

Delicious and subtle.

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

6/10

Value:

8/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Ben "The Captain" G.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

8.6 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

7/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Ally "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" G.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

9.4 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Alissa "LadyPonch" P.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

8.8 / 10

Lisa sets a high precedent. The toppings were all complementary, high points for the pickles!

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Andrew "The Moo Pie Pirate" O.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

8.2 / 10

Very tasty and complex - the onions in particular were sensational. But the salad made it too slippery and difficult without adding significant impact to the burger. An excellent piece of beef all around though.

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Zaida "Beefy Dishy" D.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

10.0 / 10

My mom told me if I had anything nice to say... Don't say anything at all!

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Samuel "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" L.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

8.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

5/10

Loïc "Bocuse Cheap " D.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

9.4 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Lisa "P.E.T.A (People. Eat. Tasty. Animals) " L.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

9.8 / 10

It's mine and I love it!

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Fay "The Swanson" L.

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"

Rating

7.8 / 10

I knew stepping through the window threshold meant meating my maker-my mother... although she was sporting a smug Clintony Trump grin and squeagy eyes, her slider was a tasty creation. As for Andrew- if he had a high pitched girly voice, I don't think anyone would listen to him.

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

7/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Chris "Scientaste" W.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

9.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Samuel "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" L.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

7.2 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

5/10

Andrew "The Moo Pie Pirate" O.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

I'm biased but that is a damn tasty burger. Rich and luxuriant as any Frenchman would desire. Hands off Jean-Peroux-Francois.

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Karina "Beef Stroganoff" D.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

8.6 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

9/10

Will "Squilly" S.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

Toasted bun was A+. Everything came together with perfection

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Loïc "Bocuse Cheap " D.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

9.2 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Pamela "Ground Beef Grail-Seeker" C.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

8.0 / 10

Gruyere and pepper shine through

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

7/10

Value:

7/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Pamela "Ground Beef Grail-Seeker" C.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

8.0 / 10

Gruyere and pepper shine through

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

7/10

Value:

7/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Jennifer "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" C.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

6.0 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

5/10

Toppings:

6/10

Value:

5/10

Harmoniousness:

7/10

Ally "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" G.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

9.2 / 10

This is great! Thank you!

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Alissa "LadyPonch" P.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

9.0 / 10

Fay has outdone herself once again. Complex, decadent and great use of gruyere. 5 Michelin stars!

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Philippe "Taste Bud" T.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

9.4 / 10

Delicious!

Rating Details

Taste:

7/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Zaida "Beefy Dishy" D.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

Delicious!!

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Greg "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" T.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

8.4 / 10

Simple yet complex, tasty , beautifully done. Who invited Andrew?

Rating Details

Taste:

8/10

Texture:

8/10

Toppings:

8/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

8/10

Doug "Vegan1" O.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

8.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

5/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Lisa "P.E.T.A (People. Eat. Tasty. Animals) " L.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

6.6 / 10

It's hers and I don't like it!

Rating Details

Taste:

6/10

Texture:

6/10

Toppings:

6/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

5/10

Ben "The Captain" G.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

9.6 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

9/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Noely "Burgerlicious" Q.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

First slider of the night and it was amazing

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

John "Rare" O.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

9.6 / 10

Perfectly harmonious.

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

9/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Fay "The Swanson" L.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

10.0 / 10

Make sliders great again.

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

10/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Jennifer "Ground Beef Grail-seeker" C.

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger

Rating

9.8 / 10

Rating Details

Taste:

10/10

Texture:

9/10

Toppings:

10/10

Value:

10/10

Harmoniousness:

10/10

Burgers

Adrian's "Bloody Beetnik" Burger
9.2/10

Lisa's "Mama Mona's Moo Pie"
8.8/10

Fay's "Pépé Le Poive" Burger
9.0/10