The Feast of the Immaculate Conception 2026
Reservations
This session has concluded.
The Meaty Details
Burger Club 2.0 is here. Take a long, greasy gander at what our ham-hocked hands hath wrought - a snazzy new design, searchable burgers and restaurants, and a profile page that allows you to revisit your meatiest memories, and so much more...
If you happen to be free this coming Saturday at 3PM, we're going to take this lip-smacking Lamborghini of a new website for a little test drive, with a patty-pounding pilgrimage back to the place where it all began lo those many years ago... celebrating The Feast of the Immaculate Conception of Burger Club at Whitman's East Village.
Overall Verdict
Consolidated scores from 8 ratings
Member Reviews
It was a glory to gather once more under the beefy banner of Burger Club. Whitmans remains stalwart, if never singular or spectacular. The Hound burger was a bit overcooked and the lack of AC not great for the bowels of July – but the company was fantastic, the beer was cold, and there were Tots... We’re back baby. Special thanks to Greg, Blossom, and Claude for their hard work on the 2.0 site!
A return to a glorious beginning. Not perfectly cooked, not perfectly served but the nostalgia does a lot of work. The beefy blend is a hit, the tots are great. Andrew actually showed up on time so he's batting a solid 6.3
Solid burger. Nothing special. I'm moderately pleased but distracted by a child making me color a backhoe.
It's hot down here!
Medium-rare (as I asked) might have been better and juicier but this was definitely medium or well and on a drier side. Bacon and crisps added to the texture but overall just okay.
While this burger was delicious, it was slightly underwhelming, mainly because it was slightly dry, certainly due to being slightly overcooked. Ambience was wonderful with fun music, though slightly hot downstairs with one fan.
It was simple and just right!
The Hound! Delightful to return to a classic, but it unfortunately it was overcooked a bit and the patty felt a little salty between the bacon in the patty.
But! Nothing could bring me down on the day that Burger Club 2.0 returns.